PART II. NEED

In addition to being a basic science, cognitive science also has an ‘applied’ component. The program provides an opportunity for practical benefits to the State of Louisiana, and to the nation. For example, the development of reading skills is a focal area for cognitive scientists interested in language and learning. They will be able to work with teachers in attacking one of the highest rates of illiteracy in the nation. Cognitive scientists interested in attention and neuroscience will contribute to the understanding and treatment of attention deficit disorder. Cognitive scientists interested in artificial intelligence and experts systems are already designing systems to help in medical diagnosis. Systems for tutoring and fostering expertise are relevant to the business, military, and educational communities. Cognitive science speaks to engineers and designers creating artifacts that interact with people, to language and art teachers, to speech therapists, and to those involved in computer-aided instruction and tutoring systems.
 

1. Similar Programs at the Institution: Cognitive Science at USL

No programs are currently offered at the University of Southwestern Louisiana like the one being proposed. Nor has such a program been offered in the past.

Interest in cognitive science at USL reaches back to 1988 when members of the philosophy, psychology, linguistics, and computer science disciplines formed a cognitive science group. The group met regularly for seminars and colloquia. Its colloquium series is now a regular feature of the group’s activities and has included distinguished lecturers from the United States and abroad. In the 1991-92 academic year, the first graduate level course in cognitive science was offered by the group. The same year saw the admission, by USL’s Center for Advanced Computer Studies, of the first Ph.D. student in computer science with a research focus in cognitive science. Since then, several other students have been admitted to the Ph.D. program in CACS under the same arrangement. Their advisors are members of the cognitive science group many of whom hold adjunct appointments in CACS. Two doctoral degrees were recently awarded in CACS for cognitive-science related projects, and several theses are approaching completion.

Aside from a taste of cognitive science in CACS, then, there is no doctoral program at USL where cognitive science can be studied. There is no graduate program in psychology that allows a specialization in cognition; no graduate program in linguistics; and no program in cognitive neuroscience.
 

2. Similar Programs in Louisiana and Elsewhere: The Emergence of Cognitive Science

Cognitive science began to crystalize nearly twenty years ago. In 1977, the Cognitive Science Society was formed and the journal Cognitive Science began publication. Textbooks, monographs and advanced works of reference in cognitive science continue to be published by both distinguished academic presses such as the MIT Press, the university presses of Harvard, Cambridge, and Oxford, and by commercial presses such as Kluwer, Erlbaum, and Basic Books.

Over the past decade, academic programs in cognitive science, both at the undergraduate and graduate levels, have been set up in the United States, Canada, United Kingdom, Australia, and the Netherlands. They are now flourishing at Berkeley, Pennsylvania, Brown, Carnegie-Mellon, Harvard, Illinois, Stanford, Indiana, Vassar, and Johns Hopkins, as well as at Alberta, Carleton University, McGill, and Waterloo in Canada. Among southern universities, Florida, Florida State, Georgia Tech, South Florida, Georgia, Texas and Jacksonville State have undergraduate or graduate programs in cognitive science or closely related fields.

Although there are interdisciplinary Ph.D. programs in neuroscience at Louisiana State University Medical Center and Tulane that providing training in areas such as behavioral neuroscience, molecular neurobiology, and neuroendocrinology, there is, at present, no graduate program in Louisiana that focuses directly on mainstream cognitive science. Not only are doctoral programs in this area absent in Louisiana, but they are also absent from the neighboring states of Mississippi and Arkansas. A cognitive science program at USL will have a significant impact in this region of the United States.

Most notable for USL, perhaps, is the fact that Tulane and Rice have recently developed undergraduate programs in cognitive science, while there is no comparable graduate program in Arkansas, Louisiana, or Texas into which these students may enroll. USL, therefore, seems to have an opportunity to fill a significant niche in the region. (letter from Kenneth Aizawa, Chair of the Philosophy Department and holder of the Charles T. Beard Chair of Philosophy, Centenary College; see Appendix G).
 
3. Justification of Need

Undergraduate and graduate students in a number of departments at the university have indicated support for and interest in applying to a new program in cognitive science. The infrastructure is already in place at USL and the time is appropriate for establishing the first such doctoral program in Louisiana.

We have already mentioned some of the practical benefits to the educational, professional, and business communities in Louisiana. The program also has the following benefits:

                    a. Enhancing Professional Opportunities

The growth of cognitive science has created a demand for cognition experts. In higher education, there is now vigorous recruitment of cognitive science faculty in the ‘Employment Opportunities’ sections of the relevant professional journals. Among nearly 20 advertised positions in cognitive science and closely related areas in the December 1994 issue of the employment bulletin section of the American Psychological Society’s Observer are positions at Alabama in Huntsville, California State in Sacramento, San Jose State, Georgia Tech, Indiana, Northeastern (Boston), Wellesley College, MIT, Gustavas Adolphus College (Minnesota), Montana State, Pittsburgh, Carnegie-Mellon, Brown, Vanderbilt, Utah, and Washington State. The January and February 1995 issues of the same publication each included 7 new advertisements in this area. The March 1995 issue of the American Psychological Association’s Monitor included 22 relevant job advertisements. The March 1995 issue of Communications of the ACM, a leading periodical in computer science, has also advertised for faculty and research positions in cognitive science.

More recently, the October 1996 issue of the APS Observer advertised 18 positions in cognition and/or cognitive science, including openings at Berkeley, Emory University, the University of Montana, SUNY-Buffalo, UNC-Greensboro, the University of Virginia, and Rice University. An additional 16 positions in closely related areas were advertised: 1 position in psycholinguistics; 2 positions in perceptual processes; 3 positions each in areas specifying social cognition or cognitive development, and 7 positions in cognitive neuroscience. In that same month, the APA Monitor listed an additional 16 positions in cognition/cognitive science, including 2 NIMH post-doctoral fellowships at Carnegie-Mellon University. Closely related areas accounted for another 11 non-overlapping job announcements. And in computer science journals and web sites for the same month, additional positions were advertised at schools such as North Carolina State, the University of Texas, and the Colorado School of Mines.

Positions advertised as of October 1996 also included openings in industry. Applications for people with backgrounds in cognitive science or a closely related area were being solicited by corporations such as Texas Instruments, ADIA Technical Services, CDI Information Services, and the Mei Technology Corporation.

In general, the field of Cognitive Science is doing very well in scientific, educational and practical terms. The increasing emphasis on man-machine interaction has led to many job opportunities for our graduates. As an extreme case, Don Norman has gone from being a Professor of Cognitive Science (at UCSD) to Vice-President for Advanced Development at Apple. (letter from Jerome A. Feldman, Professor at Berkeley and Director, International Computer Science Institute; see Appendix G)

By obtaining an advanced degree and training at the Ph.D. level, USL graduates will be able to respond to such demands on a competitive basis.

One important objective of the proposed Ph.D. program will be to train the next generation of university professors and researchers in cognitive science. They will be formally trained cognitive scientists, in contrast to those who have become cognitive scientists by osmosis and evolution. There is a striking parallel with the development of computer science in the early 1970s. Cognitive science appears to be in the process of coalescing into a unified discipline. USL has an opportunity to be at the forefront of this scientific revolution.

Graduates will have the opportunity for employment outside academia. A knowledge of cognitive science will be beneficial to teachers and learning consultants. In the legal profession, there is a demand for experts on jury reasoning, eye-witness identification, comprehension of legal instructions, and memory. (One person involved in this program regularly consults nationwide with lawyers on these issues.) The inability of many Americans to understand tax forms is notorious; research projects by cognitive scientists examine how to present instructions in a manner easy to understand, particularly under high-arousal conditions (such as jury deliberation and emergency fire exit instructions). Many private hospitals will benefit from experts knowledgeable about the cognitive processes of closed-head-injury patients, Alzheimer’s patients, or other amnesiacs. Many private businesses seek software that requires the contribution of people familiar with cognitive science.

These examples of cognitive science-related employment opportunities could easily be multiplied. They are not limited to the State of Louisiana, although employment for people in cognitive science is available here. In the current Information Age, specialists on information will fill new job descriptions.

                    b. Enhancing Educational, Scholarly and Research Opportunities Centenary College is in the earliest stages of the development of a cognitive science program, and we are interested in the possibility of a Ph.D. program in cognitive science at the University of Southwestern Louisiana. These simultaneous developments hold out the promise of numerous beneficial interactions within the state...I believe collaborations among the educational institutions in the state are a significant means of expanding the educational opportunities for Louisiana’s young people and I look forward to great accomplishments from a Centenary-USL interaction. (letter from Robert B. Bareikis, Provost & Dean, Centenary College; see Appendix G)

A Ph.D. program in cognitive science at USL will attract students not only from Louisiana (for example, from the developing undergraduate cognitive science emphasis at Centenary College) but also from neighboring states. Without the program, most of these students would enroll in programs elsewhere in the country. Moreover, offering advanced courses in cognitive science will stimulate interest in applications: ‘Users’ of cognitive science in other disciplines, including those in engineering, architecture, industrial design, robotics, computer science, education and communicative disorders, will be able to receive formal and systematic instruction in cognitive topics relevant to their needs. There is much practical ‘spin-off’ from such a program.

In addition to practical spin-off, however, the program will enable establishing cooperative research programs involving various disciplines. For example, we anticipate forging strong links with people such as Jeanette Parker in the College of Education to apply cognitive science methods and models to research issues concerning teaching and learning in the classroom.

The proposed Ph.D. program will help attract outside grants (see below). Establishing new graduate fellowships will enhance the University’s reputation.

The program also has the potential for the cross-fertilization of ideas across areas that might, at first blush, seem far-removed from cognitive science:

I have been watching and - to the extent my own training and knowledge will allow - participating in and, most especially, profiting from the work of the Cognitive Science group at USL. What I myself have learned has been significantly helpful both in my teaching and in my own research... There will of course be more and more such academic cross-pollination, not only aiding and improving all of our work but, even more importantly, the training of our students... in our various departments. That is, the academic benefits of programs like this are pervasive: they spread into, and distinctly improve, all sorts of academic activity. (letter from Prof. Burton Raffel, Eminent Scholar and Professor of English at USL; winner of the French-American Foundation 1991 Translation Prize for his translation of Rabelais’s Gargantua and Pantagruel; see Appendix G)

                    c. Financial Benefits Growth in advanced research in cognitive science has been accompanied by increases of funding for cognitive science research. The National Science Foundation now has programs in "Neuroengineering" and "Neuroscience" and "Information, Robotics and Intelligence Systems" which subsume computational neuroscience, cognitive systems, and machine intelligence. There is a program in "Speech, Text, Image, and Multimedia Advanced Technology Effort" which will be of interest to cognitive scientists at USL working in discourse and speech processing. The National Institute of Mental Health is seeking proposals for the computational modeling of processes in cognitive science and neuroscience. These are all components of cognitive science. The Air Force Office of Scientific Research likewise advertises funding programs in cognition, neuroscience, and perception/recognition. Other agencies maintain related programs (for example, the Office of Naval Research divisions of Neuroscience and Life Science and Human Factors). By establishing a Ph.D. program at USL, the university will be in a stronger position to compete for research dollars.

I know that in tight budget times there are always more proposals than money to fund them, but I truly believe that this program would bring a significant amount of attention to USL in a growing and very important area of scientific research. I should also mention that as a field Cognitive Science typically generates more grant funding than other disciplines in the behavioral sciences. ( Michael Tomasello, Associate Editor, Child Development and Journal of Comparative Psychology; Professor of Psychology at Emory University; see Appendix G)

                    d. Uniqueness of the USL Program The program at USL is quite distinctive. The conjunction of resources at USL’s New Iberia Research Center with those in cognitive psychology, linguistics, philosophy of mind, artificial intelligence and computational modeling will result in a Ph.D. program that can span human, machine and animal cognition. The program will thus be able to focus on comparative cognition, making it unique among doctoral programs in the country. The USL New Iberia Research Center allows students and faculty at the main campus of USL and scientists from across the world to conduct research with an extraordinary collection of over 6000 primates, including the world’s second-largest captive colony of chimpanzees. Unlike other chimpanzee facilities, NIRC’s physical design and management provide an unprecedented opportunity to conduct research in comparative cognition. As a result, the proposed program would be the only one of its kind to have access to such a remarkable and rare resource. It is the interweaving of research facilities and research interests at USL that differentiates this program.

The program as currently envisioned is distinctive, interdisciplinary, and unusually well integrated. The faculty expertise, facilities, and program philosophy will immediately position it at the cutting edge of some of the most important contemporary issues in cognitive science. Being familiar with the credentials of many of the participants I am confident that the program already represents a critical intellectual mass with the kind of viability that will be conducive to achieving national distinction and eventually considerable prominence. I should also note that the presence of a comparative cognition component to this program, coupled with the excellent primate research facilities at the New Iberia Research Center, will make it not only unique among cognitive science programs throughout the country, but will almost certainly attract an unusually large number of distinctive and highly qualified doctoral students from many diverse backgrounds. (letter from Gordon G. Gallup, Jr., Professor of Psychology, State University of New York at Albany; see Appendix G).